WHY THOMAS JEFFERSON WOULD HAVE CONDEMNED THE SUPER BOWL . . . AND SUPPORTED THE NRA

(I don’t much care about the Super Bowl and rarely watch unless Peyton Manning–an old Tennessee Volunteer, like me–happens to be playing.  I originally wrote the short post below two years ago, when Manning and the Broncos also were in the championship game, and got clobbered.  I’m pulling for a different outcome this year, but not too optimistic about it.  At any rate, I thought you be interested in Jefferson’s thoughts on the kind of exercise best conducive to health.  Given all that we are learning about the connection between football and the danger of repetitive brain injury, there is something prescient about his warning against violent sports.  I don’t expect that his recommended substitute will get much traction, however.)

**********

These last couple of days I have been reading a fair amount in the correspondence of Thomas Jefferson, and just yesterday I came across some of Jefferson’s ruminations on the importance of exercise that might interest you, especially given the likelihood that almost all of us will soon be watching a certain athletic contest.

The comments I have in mind come from a letter that Jefferson wrote to his nephew, Peter Carr, in the summer of 1785. Carr was his wife’s brother’s son, and Jefferson seems to have taken great interest in his upbringing after Carr’s father died when young Peter was only three. By 1785 Jefferson’s wife had also passed away, and it may be that Jefferson saw in the teenaged Peter a tangible link to his beloved Martha. Perhaps he even saw in Peter the son he would never have. Whatever his motive, Jefferson devoted considerable attention to Carr’s education, and he counseled him frequently on the path his nephew must follow if he aspired to a career of accomplishment and service worthy of a Virginia gentleman.

Thomas Jefferson sat for this portrait by Mather Brown in 1786, the year after he wrote to his nephew Peter Carr.

Thomas Jefferson sat for this portrait by Mather Brown in 1786, the year after he wrote to his nephew Peter Carr.

Although only forty-two years old, Jefferson in 1785 had already compiled an amazing record of publish service. In the past decade alone, he had served as a delegate to the Second Continental Congress, been the principle author of the Declaration of Independence, held the post of governor of Virginia, and was now representing the United States as ambassador to France. “Mortified” by reports of his nephew’s slow academic progress, Jefferson wrote from Paris on the 19th of August to exhort his fifteen-year-old nephew to greater effort. Did Peter not realize that “every day you lose, will retard a day your entrance on that public stage whereon you may begin to be useful to yourself?” (It’s just a suspicion, but Jefferson may not have been cut out to work with teenagers.)

Jefferson began by focusing on his young charge’s character. “The purest integrity” and “the most chaste honour” must be his nephew’s “first object.” “The defect of these virtues can never be made up” by other accomplishments. Then after integrity comes intellect. “An honest heart being the first blessing,” Jefferson explained, “a knowing head is the second.” And so the future president lay out a course of reading for the teenager. He must begin with “antient” history–“reading everything in the original” language, of course–and proceed from there to Greek and Roman poetry, followed by a systematic study of philosophy and ethics beginning with Plato and Cicero.

But the body was important as well as the heart and head. To maximize his academic progress, Peter should set aside at least two hours every day for exercise, “for health must not be sacrificed to learning.” “A strong body,” Jefferson lectured, “makes the mind strong.” (Michelle Obama could not have said it better.) But what kind of exercise should Peter pursue? Jefferson left nothing to doubt. “Walking is the best possible exercise,” he instructed, but not just any kind of walking. “Never think of taking a book with you” while you walk, Jefferson stressed. Instead, “let your gun . . . be the constant companion of your walks.” While “this gives a moderate exercise to the body, it gives boldness, enterprize, and independance [sic] to the mind.”

And what about more modern kinds of sports, you ask? Peter should avoid “games played with the ball and others of that nature,” Jefferson cautioned his nephew. They “are too violent for the body and stamp no character on the mind.”

 Thomas Jefferson would advise him not to play tomorrow.

Thomas Jefferson would advise him not to play tomorrow.

One response to “WHY THOMAS JEFFERSON WOULD HAVE CONDEMNED THE SUPER BOWL . . . AND SUPPORTED THE NRA

  1. 6 Feb 2016

    1/ Well, I also think walking is great exercise and if one avoids being plugged into an iPod or some such device then it is a great time to let one’s mind wander over hill and dale also. It wouldn’t be wise to carry a gun (rifle) these days. But many times I carry my camera so I am able to do some great shooting that way.

    2/ re: Thomas J’s advice to Peter that he should avoid “games played with the ball and others of that nature,” since they “are too violent for the body and stamp no character on the mind.”

    I didn’t know football was that old a sport!

    3/ Just had an e-mail from the choir director at our church that she was moving the choir practice up so that the members could be home for the opening kick off! OK, its not quite as bad as watching gladiators fight…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s